ser vs estar

29 Sep

visuals2015

 intro ser_estar (FILE)

Having a hard time getting students to understand the difference between these two verbs?  Try this!  Introduce it contextually with an image.

Like any lesson that begins with a visual, I start by asking them for words and then sentences.  (reference: Scoring oral practice)

But the second part of the presentation is a chart that comes up to talk about the man who is hiding underneath the family.  (Did you notice him the first time??? – I got this visual from http://awkwardfamilyphotos.com)

Picture1

The chart is divided between “Descripción” and “Situación”.  In answering the questions (which may need more guidance depending on the level), the students are using ser and estar naturally.

I can then break it down into the “list of rules” that I have found in many classrooms – What did we use for Description?  We said his origin, his nationality, we used possessive to say he’s the Uncle of the family, we described him physically and by personality, we said his occupation…  And for his Situation, we said his location, his position, his “temporary condition” (feeling), and we used a progressive to say what he is doing.

Just to remind them, ask about the time – I personally develop this use a lot more when we are planning our classroom Quinceañeras.  I use that event to remind them that:
  • we use es/son to tell time
  • while we usually use estar to talk about location, we use es/son to say where an event takes place

If I have time in another class session, I’ll give them each their group Barbie dolls (I use these for a few lessons) and have them create all of that info about their dolls.
*I spotted a missing accent in one of my questions. Just be sure to fix that if you use the file.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

James River Film Journal

Writing on the art of film & film as art.

Mi clase de español

Mi clase es tu clase

Mi Clase es Su Clase

Sharing ideas from one Spanish teacher to another.

senor fernie

a journey into the world of comprehensible input

Las clases de Stilson

Traveling the proficiency path, one step at a time

Lugar para pensar

A place to think about my language lessons, and how to make them better

Somewhere to Share

Experiments in Spanish Teaching

Señora B

Spanish Teacher and Learner

SpanishPlans.org

Facilitating language acquisition through comprehensible input

La Clase de la Señora Dentlinger

My journey to become a better Spanish teacher

Resources and ideas for language teachers

Ideas and resources for teaching Modern Foreign Languages

La Maestra Bilingue

Resources for the bilingual teacher

Creative Language Class

Ideas, solutions, and inspiration for world language teachers

i run read teach

A blog about running, reading, and teaching!

Maris Hawkins

Best practices and reflections about my Middle and Upper School Spanish classroom

My generation of polyglots

A language teacher's blog by Mike Peto

MJ's Comprehensible Input

CI rubber meets the road

%d bloggers like this: